Lying Lunatic

Time for some more from the Lying Lunatic.

As ever, he is engaged on:

Mission:Make people believe Madeleine died before the 3rd May

Consequently, he comes out with this bollocks. Bennett's bollocks in blue, in keeping with tradition 

So let's now look at a summary of Inspector Pinho's report. Remember the issue is not whether there was a 'mini-sail' that morning - there was - but whether Madeleine went with the rest of the group.

Place: Praia da Luz, Lagos Officer responsible: Manuel Pinho, Inspector - SUMMARY:

Pinho: "Today (10 May 07), accompanied by Joao Barreiras and Catriona Baker, the 'nanny' responsible for the missing minor, we retraced the places and times at which they left the resort area to go to Praia da Luz. We were told by Catriona that they went to the beach on Thursday between 10 and 11 o'clock…and that Catriona, with Madeleine and 4 or 5 more children, walked toward the beach - about 100 metres".

But Alice Standley accompanied the children on the route and on the boat. Three children sailed with her.  Chris Unsworth transported the children in a red amphibious boat (a life-saving boat) until the boat reached the open sea, and, a few minutes later, returned them to the beach to pick up three other children from the group.

Both state that the children did not have any contact with anyone else during the time they were at the beach, as was the case also during their walk to the beach.

So, both these witnesses, according to Inspector Pinho, deny that Cat Baker went sailing with Madeleine’s group that morning. Neither, it appears, did either Alice Standley or Chris Unsworth say that Madeleine was in either of the boats of three children that went sailing that morning. There were 7 children in the Lobsters group.

It looks like the other six children in the group all went sailing, in two boats of three each, but that Madeleine did not.


So we have to make a choice.

Do we believe Cat Baker?

Or Alice Standley and Chris Unsworth?

So, lets see what the report ACTUALLY says, because when Baldy ''summarises'' something it usually means the truth gets lost. The following is the actual report, not Baldy's interpretation of it

 Description and Result of Activity:

On this date, in the company of my colleague Joao Barreiras and Catriona Baker, the nanny responsible for the missing minor, we reconstructed the locations and the moments when they left the resort, in the direction of the Praia da Luz.

A photographic report was made, which is attached. 

We were told by Catriona, that in the last days they went to the beach on Tuesday afternoon (01 of May 2007), between 15H30 and 16h30, on Wednesday (the next day) at the same time and on Thursday between 10 and 11h00 (see attached map).


The following route was taken: 
1. The parents leave the children in the Mark Warner “BABY CLUB”, which is situated next to the principal resort reception which is open 24 hours; 
2. Next, Catriona, with MADELEINE and 4 or 5 other children, headed in the direction of the beach on foot. The walk was about 100 metres, although not in a straight line;
3. The infant educator always went in front with the children following, and all held on to a “summy snake” (a long snake-like object that allows the children to walk in single file);
4. After leaving the “BABY CLUB”, they descended the stairs to the main reception, went through the entrance gate and crossed Rua Direita (principal road of Praia da Luz) in the direction of Beco das Palmeiras; 
5. Next, they turned right in the direction of Beco de Nordeste, and afterwards turned left and descended stairs next to a house called “Casa Ortiga” and which is numbered 17; 
6. At the bottom of these stairs is situated Travessa das Redes; 
7. Upon crossing this street, they descended along a parking area, in the direction of the boardwalk, which is situated along the beach; 
8. Afterwards entering the beach, they walked along the boardwalk until they arrived at a zone with a red awning and various parasols; 

During the first two days, the children played and made activities in the sand. On Thursday they sailed close to the beach. 

On this day the sailed in a small yellow catamaran. 

Employee Alice Standley accompanied the children during the sailing trip made in this boat. Three children at a time would travel in her company. 

Employee Chris Unswork transported the children, in a red amphibious boat (life boat), to the embarkation and a few minutes later, would return them to the beach and then pick up the 3 remaining children from the group.

All state that the children did have any not contact with anyone else during the time they were at the beach, neither during their walk to the beach. 

All state that they did not see anyone suspicious looking at the children or in the surrounding areas. 

Catriona states that she no notice anything out of the ordinary during the trips she made to the beach or returning to the resort. 

Signed by the officer in charge.

So, let's count up Baldy's lies, shall we?

''But Alice Standley accompanied the children on the route and on the boat.''

Well, the report actually says '' Employee Alice Standley accompanied the children during the sailing trip made in this boat. Three children at a time would travel in her company.''
There is no mention of her accompanying the children on the route.

''Both state that the children did not have any contact with anyone else during the time they were at the beach, as was the case also during their walk to the beach.''

The report actually says '' All state that the children did have any not contact with anyone else during the time they were at the beach, neither during their walk to the beach. ''
All includes Catriona, who Baldy seems to imply was absent

''So, both these witnesses, according to Inspector Pinho, deny that Cat Baker went sailing with Madeleine’s group that morning.''

Complete, barefaced, Baldy lie. They say nothing of the kind.

'' Neither, it appears, did either Alice Standley or Chris Unsworth say that Madeleine was in either of the boats of three children that went sailing that morning''

At no point in the report is this referred to. There is no indication that they were asked, or that the question needed to be asked 

'' There were 7 children in the Lobsters group.''

Lie. The register clearly shows there were six children present, including Madeleine

''It looks like the other six children in the group all went sailing, in two boats of three each, but that Madeleine did not.''

Complete lie. Brazen, barefaced lie.  

So I make that 6 barefaced lies in one post. Defend that, arsehead.